Then there’s the fact that these games simply run poorly when they’re already not graphically impressive, with the games looking like upscaled 3DS games. Having played the game for 8-odd hours, I’ll say this review is largely on the mark, and I thank @AlexOlney for mentioning the performance problems. I’d give it a score of 6-7, but that’s on a scale where 5 is an average score. I think it’s essentially the same as an 8 in this site’s scoring system. Basically since reviews are in theory to help other people Read the full info here. To continue process you have to dowloand FileZilla from here if you don’t already have it. they need some more objective criteria than just whatever the hell the reviewer feels like giving it.
It doesn’t have to be 100% objective but it should not be difficult to say why one game scores higher than another. @SuperEndriu now keep in mind I understand we can’t create an absolutely perfect scale to line all games up side by side and know exactly where they fall. What I’m saying is if I look at two games and they’re equal on all fronts except one has better graphics then the one with better graphics is the better game. Likewise if two games are equal on all fronts except one has more content then that one is the better game.
If a game lacks content then I expect something else to make up for it, difficulty, replayability etc. If something is lacking and other things don’t make up for it then the game scores lower. Basically when the best defense of a review people can come up with is he gave it a higher score because he felt like it, it basically acknowledges it’s just a fanboy review.
While there is always some subjectivity there is a such thing as objective criticism. We know what makes good and bad writing, and good and bad technical performance in a game. We know about visuals, pacing, character development and on and on and on. But again even the older players fall mainly into the more casual group, I know we do not always want to admit it, but core hobby gamers that post on internet forums are in the minority.
Endless Running Game
You gotta love how pretty much anyone that gives these games criticism and points out Gamefreak’s lies is automatically labelled as being "Entitled" and "Haters". To be honest, I only have seen gamexplains review and the graphics aren’t terrible. @Bondi_Surfer The differences in the two versions of any pokemon game are just in what pokemon you can catch. There’s about a dozen that are in one game and not the other to encourage trading.
I feel like reviews should be well reasoned and scores shouldn’t be based on how much a fanboy of the game someone is. While I understand some level of subjective variance we should be able to deduce from the review why one game got a higher score than another. Basically there’s no logic, no reasoning, nothing concrete to point to, the review is just whatever someone feels like and all the text and scores are utterly meaningless. @antdickens I’m suggesting a review should actually mean something.
Of course we don’t always get such clean comparisons that’s why I see it as a give and take. If the graphics are lacking then I expect the gameplay to make up for it.
- It doesn’t serve a whole lot of purpose beyond sharing with friends and others online, kind of like a Guild Card in Monster Hunter without the tiny gameplay benefits, but I still had fun making mine just how I wanted it.
- I’d still like better cutscenes, companion Pokemon, the complete Pokedex, and a more visually interesting Wild Area, but nitpicks are just not very effective when everything else was such a complete joy to play.
- The way they respect my time is wonderful, and the removal of monotony from random encounters and other odds and ends distills it down to only the pure and charming fun of capturing, training, and battling wonderful creatures.
- These Gym Battles were one of the few places I could experiment with Dynamaxing and Gigantamaxing my Pokemon, and I’m glad for the limitation.
- And hey, if I’m missing any tedious repetition, I can always get back into breeding.
Mario Tennis Aces (For Nintendo Switch)
They are like Glaceons who haven’t quite mastered adulthood yet. @BlackenedHalo Don’t get me wrong, this game looks just plain mediocre but Kirby Star Allies and Daemon X Machina both got a 7. Nintendolife shouldn’t automatically be assumed to give it a super good score. That said, the review sounds like as though the score should be even lower.